Home / Bible Reference / Bible Facts / Books & Authorship
Quick Summary
First Timothy opens by naming the apostle Paul as its author and Timothy, his younger coworker in Ephesus, as its recipient. For most of church history no one doubted that claim. Since the early nineteenth century, though, many scholars have argued that 1 Timothy, along with 2 Timothy and Titus, was written by a later follower of Paul who wrote in his name. The two views produce two dates. If Paul wrote it, 1 Timothy dates to about 62-64 CE, after a release from his first Roman imprisonment. If a disciple wrote it, the most common estimate is about 80-100 CE. Either way, the letter was known and quoted by the early second century.
Scripture Reference
Book: 1 Timothy 1-6
Authorship claim: 1 Timothy 1:1-2
Key setting text: 1 Timothy 1:3
Church office passages: 1 Timothy 3:1-13 and 5:17-22
Related letters: 2 Timothy and Titus (the Pastoral Epistles)
Timothy's background: Acts 16:1-5; 2 Timothy 1:5
Translation quoted: NRSV
Who Wrote 1 Timothy?
The letter's first line is direct: "Paul, an apostle of Christ Jesus by the command of God our Savior" (1 Timothy 1:1). It is addressed to "Timothy, my loyal child in the faith" (1:2). The writer speaks in the first person throughout, recalls his own past as "a blasphemer, a persecutor, and a man of violence" (1:13), and gives Timothy personal instructions about how to lead the church.
First Timothy belongs to a group of three letters called the Pastoral Epistles, a name that goes back to the eighteenth century. Unlike Paul's letters to congregations, these three are written to individual church leaders about the care of churches. Any answer about who wrote 1 Timothy usually applies to 2 Timothy and Titus as well.
Who Was Timothy?
Timothy was Paul's closest coworker. Acts introduces him at Lystra as the son of a Jewish believing mother and a Greek father, a young disciple well regarded by the churches, whom Paul took along on his second journey (Acts 16:1-3). The story of that calling is told in Acts 16:1-5: Timothy Joins Paul and Silas. Second Timothy names his mother Eunice and grandmother Lois as the ones who first taught him the faith (2 Timothy 1:5).
Paul names Timothy as co-sender of six letters (2 Corinthians, Philippians, Colossians, 1 and 2 Thessalonians, and Philemon) and sent him on delicate errands to Thessalonica, Corinth, and Philippi. By the time of 1 Timothy he is still young enough that the writer has to say, "Let no one despise your youth" (1 Timothy 4:12).
The Traditional View: Paul Wrote 1 Timothy
The early church accepted 1 Timothy as Paul's without debate. Around 180 CE, Irenaeus of Lyon opened his major work Against Heresies by quoting 1 Timothy 1:4 and attributing it to the apostle. The Muratorian Fragment, an early list of accepted books, includes the letters to Timothy and Titus as Paul's. From then until the 1800s, Christian readers took the opening verse at face value.
Scholars who defend Paul's authorship today, including Luke Timothy Johnson, Philip Towner, and William Mounce, make several arguments:
The letter claims Paul as author, and the early church, which rejected other letters written in his name, accepted this one.
Its personal details, such as the reference to Hymenaeus and Alexander (1:20), read like real history rather than literary decoration.
Differences in vocabulary make sense for a different subject (church order instead of theology), a different audience (a trusted colleague instead of a congregation), and a writer late in life.
Paul often used a secretary, and a secretary given more freedom could explain the change in style.
The Critical View: A Disciple Wrote in Paul's Name
In 1807 the German theologian Friedrich Schleiermacher argued that 1 Timothy could not be Paul's. Within a generation scholars had extended the doubts to all three Pastoral Epistles. Today many commentators, including Martin Dibelius and Hans Conzelmann, Raymond Collins, and Jouette Bassler, conclude that a later follower of Paul wrote them. I. Howard Marshall took a middle path he called "allonymity": a close associate writing after Paul's death to carry his teaching forward, with no intent to deceive.
The main arguments are these:
Vocabulary and style. The Pastorals use hundreds of words that appear nowhere in Paul's undisputed letters. A favorite word, eusebeia ("godliness"), appears ten times in the Pastorals and never in the letters everyone agrees Paul wrote.
Theology. "Faith" often means a body of teaching to guard (1 Timothy 6:20) rather than a person's trust in Christ, Paul's usual meaning.
Church structure. The letter assumes formal offices of overseer, elder, and deacon (1 Timothy 3:1-13; 5:17-22), plus an enrolled order of widows (5:9-16). Many scholars think this reflects a later, more settled church.
Fit with Paul's life. The setting of 1:3, with Paul leaving Timothy in Ephesus while he travels to Macedonia, is hard to place anywhere in the story told by Acts.
Writing in a revered teacher's name was a known practice in the ancient world, and scholars disagree about how the early church would have viewed it. A similar debate surrounds Who Wrote Ephesians? and Who Wrote Colossians?, and the larger picture is laid out in How Ephesians Fits into Paul's Letters.
Middle Positions: The Secretary and the Fragments
Some scholars look for a way between the two views. C. F. D. Moule suggested that Luke, Paul's companion, wrote the Pastorals for or after Paul, noting that "only Luke is with me" (2 Timothy 4:11) and that the Pastorals share some vocabulary with Luke and Acts. Background on Luke appears in Who Wrote Luke? and Who Wrote Acts?
P. N. Harrison proposed a "fragment hypothesis": genuine notes from Paul, mostly preserved in 2 Timothy, worked into letters completed later. Few scholars hold either theory in its original form today, but both show how seriously interpreters have taken the letter's personal details.
When Was 1 Timothy Written?
The date depends on the author. If Paul wrote 1 Timothy, it dates to about 62-64 CE. If a later disciple wrote it, the most common estimate is about 80-100 CE, with some scholars going later.
If Paul Wrote It: About 62-64 CE
Acts ends with Paul under house arrest in Rome for two years, around 60-62 CE (Acts 28:30-31), a scene covered in Acts 28:17-31: Paul Proclaims the Kingdom of God. Acts does not record his death. In the fourth century the historian Eusebius reported a tradition that Paul was released, traveled and preached again, and was later arrested a second time and executed under Nero.
On that reconstruction, 1 Timothy fits the gap between imprisonments. Paul leaves Timothy in Ephesus, travels to Macedonia (1 Timothy 1:3), and writes this letter, perhaps around 62-64 CE. Titus would come from the same period, and 2 Timothy from his final imprisonment shortly before his death, around 64-67 CE. For how this fits the rest of his letters, see When Did Paul Write All of His Letters?
If a Disciple Wrote It: About 80-100 CE
Scholars who see 1 Timothy as pseudonymous usually date it to the generation after Paul's death, around 80-100 CE. A few place it as late as 110-125 CE, often arguing that the "falsely called knowledge" of 1 Timothy 6:20 (gnosis in Greek) points to early Gnostic teachers. Most consider that too late, because of the outside evidence below.
1 Timothy 5:18: A Saying of Jesus Called Scripture
One verse plays a part in this debate. The writer supports paying elders by quoting two texts as "scripture": "You shall not muzzle an ox while it is treading out the grain" (Deuteronomy 25:4) and "The laborer deserves to be paid." The second line matches Jesus' words in Luke 10:7, discussed in Sending Out the Seventy (Luke 10:1-12). Some read this as evidence that Luke's Gospel was already circulating as Scripture, which favors a later date. Others think the writer was quoting a well-known saying of Jesus before any Gospel was written down.
The Outside Evidence
Whatever its date of writing, 1 Timothy was in circulation by the early second century:
Polycarp of Smyrna (writing around 110-135 CE) echoes 1 Timothy 6:7 and 6:10 in his letter to the Philippians, warning that the love of money is the beginning of troubles.
Irenaeus (around 180 CE) quotes 1 Timothy by name and attributes it to Paul.
Marcion (around 140 CE) left the Pastorals out of his collection of Paul's letters. Defenders of Paul's authorship say he rejected them for their teaching. Critics suggest he may not have known them.
Papyrus 46 (around 200 CE), the oldest surviving collection of Paul's letters, does not include the Pastorals, though its final pages are missing and scholars disagree about whether they could have fit.
That evidence makes a date after about 120 CE unlikely, and it leaves room for both main views.
| Question | Paul Wrote It | A Later Disciple Did |
|---|---|---|
| Date | About 62-64 CE | About 80-100 CE |
| Setting (1:3) | Travels after release from Rome | Literary frame for Paul's legacy |
| New vocabulary | New topic, secretary, older Paul | A different writer's style |
| Church offices | Elders already existed (Acts 20:17) | A more settled, later church |
| Key scholars | Johnson, Towner, Mounce | Dibelius-Conzelmann, Collins, Bassler |
Either way, Polycarp echoes 1 Timothy by about 110-135 CE, and Irenaeus quotes it as Paul's around 180 CE.
Ephesus: The Setting of 1 Timothy
The letter places Timothy in Ephesus, the leading city of the Roman province of Asia and home to the vast temple of Artemis. Paul spent more than two years there (Acts 19:10), and his ministry provoked a riot among the silversmiths who made shrines for the goddess, told in Acts 19:23-41: The Riot in Ephesus. For background on the city, see Historical Context of Ephesus and The Temple of Artemis.
Ephesus explains several of the letter's concerns. Paul had warned the Ephesian elders that "savage wolves" would come among them and that some of their own would distort the truth (Acts 20:29-30), a scene explored in Acts 20:13-38: Paul's Farewell to the Ephesian Elders. First Timothy opens with exactly that problem: teachers devoted to "myths and endless genealogies" (1 Timothy 1:4). Ephesus was also where Priscilla and Aquila hosted a house church (1 Corinthians 16:19).
Original Language Notes
Eusebeia: "Godliness"
Eusebeia was a common word in Greek moral writing for piety, proper reverence toward the gods and duty toward family and city. First Timothy uses it eight times and gives it Christian content. The "mystery of our religion," literally the mystery of godliness, is Christ himself, "revealed in flesh, vindicated in spirit" (1 Timothy 3:16), likely an early hymn. Its absence from Paul's undisputed letters is one of the main vocabulary arguments in the authorship debate.
Pistos ho Logos: "The Saying Is Sure"
Five times the Pastorals introduce a short creed or proverb with the formula pistos ho logos, "the saying is sure." Three appear in 1 Timothy, including the best known: "The saying is sure and worthy of full acceptance, that Christ Jesus came into the world to save sinners" (1 Timothy 1:15). These sayings look like pieces of the church's early teaching, gathered and handed on.
Episkopos, Presbyteros, Diakonos
Three Greek words describe leaders in 1 Timothy. The episkopos ("overseer," translated "bishop" in older versions) supervises. The presbyteros ("elder") is an older, respected leader. The diakonos ("deacon" or "servant") assists. In 1 Timothy, as in Acts 20:17 and 20:28, overseers and elders seem to overlap. Later centuries would separate them into distinct ranks. The early development is traced in Church Leadership and Structure in Acts. For the language of the New Testament generally, see What Is Koine Greek?
What 1 Timothy Teaches About the Church
Whoever wrote 1 Timothy, its purpose is clear: "I am writing these instructions to you so that... you may know how one ought to behave in the household of God, which is the church of the living God" (1 Timothy 3:14-15). The household image ran deep in the Greco-Roman world, and Ephesians uses it in a similar way, as discussed in The Household Code in Context.
The letter asks the church to pray "for everyone, for kings and all who are in high positions" (2:1-2), a passage that pairs well with Bible Verses About Intercessory Prayer. It sets character qualifications for leaders, collected in Bible Verses About Leadership. It organizes care for widows who had no family to support them (5:3-16), a theme gathered in Bible Verses About Widows and Orphans.
And it contains one of the most quoted (and misquoted) lines in the Bible: "the love of money is a root of all kinds of evil" (6:10). The writer does not condemn money itself. He warns against craving it and commends "godliness combined with contentment" (6:6). See Bible Verses About Money and Bible Verses About Contentment.
Why the Author and Date Matter
First Timothy is a letter the church keeps returning to at ordinations and installations. It is a pastor's letter, written to someone young in leadership, carrying a weight he did not ask for. That is true whether Paul wrote it from Macedonia in 63 or a devoted student wrote it from Ephesus a generation later.
The authorship question does matter. If Paul wrote it, we are hearing an aging apostle hand on his work to a beloved younger colleague. If a disciple wrote it, we are hearing the next generation of the church work out how to stay faithful to Paul once he was gone. Both readings make 1 Timothy a letter about passing faith from one generation to the next, which is what the church has to do in every age. Timothy received his faith from his grandmother and mother before he received it from Paul (2 Timothy 1:5), and the letter asks him to pass it on in turn. For a word to younger leaders in particular, see Bible Verses About Youth.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who wrote 1 Timothy?
The letter names Paul as its author, and the early church accepted it as his. Many modern scholars think a later follower of Paul wrote it in his name. Others, including several major commentators, still defend Paul's authorship.
When was 1 Timothy written?
If Paul wrote it, about 62-64 CE, between a first and second Roman imprisonment. If a later disciple wrote it, most scholars suggest about 80-100 CE.
Who was 1 Timothy written to?
Timothy, Paul's younger coworker, whom Paul had left in Ephesus to oversee the church there and correct false teachers (1 Timothy 1:3).
Why are 1 and 2 Timothy and Titus called the Pastoral Epistles?
The three letters are addressed to individual church leaders and deal with caring for congregations, choosing leaders, and guarding sound teaching. The label dates from the eighteenth century.
Did Paul write all three Pastoral Epistles?
Scholars usually treat the three together, but not always. Some who doubt 1 Timothy and Titus think 2 Timothy, with its many personal details, is more likely to come from Paul. For the full count of letters attributed to Paul, see How Many Letters Did Paul Write?
How old was Timothy when 1 Timothy was written?
The letter does not say. "Youth" (4:12) in the ancient world could describe someone up to about forty. If Timothy joined Paul as a young man around 49 CE, he may have been in his thirties by the early 60s.
Does it matter if Paul did not write 1 Timothy?
Christians answer this differently. Many traditions hold that the letter's authority comes from its place in the church's canon and its faithful teaching, whoever held the pen. Others believe the letter's claim to come from Paul must be accurate for it to be trustworthy.
Works Consulted
Luke Timothy Johnson, The First and Second Letters to Timothy (Anchor Yale Bible)
I. Howard Marshall, The Pastoral Epistles (International Critical Commentary)
Philip H. Towner, The Letters to Timothy and Titus (New International Commentary on the New Testament)
William D. Mounce, Pastoral Epistles (Word Biblical Commentary)
Raymond F. Collins, 1 and 2 Timothy and Titus (New Testament Library)
Martin Dibelius and Hans Conzelmann, The Pastoral Epistles (Hermeneia)
Jouette M. Bassler, 1 Timothy, 2 Timothy, Titus (Abingdon New Testament Commentaries)
Gordon D. Fee, 1 and 2 Timothy, Titus (New International Biblical Commentary)
Raymond E. Brown, An Introduction to the New Testament
The New Oxford Annotated Bible, NRSV